3 Best Neighborhoods To Live in Hunterdon County

3 Best Neighborhoods To Live in Hunterdon County

Nestled in the picturesque heart of New Jersey, Hunterdon County is renowned for its stunning landscapes, charming towns, and a quality of life that's second to none. From the lush countryside to the vibrant town centers, this county offers a range of neighborhoods that cater to various lifestyles.

No matter where you go in Hunterdon County, there is no end to the exploration and points of interest. The Samuel Fleming House, the oldest surviving home in the borough, is available for touring. You can visit the historic Hunterdon County courthouse where Bruno Hauptmann was charged with kidnapping and murdering Charles A. Lindbergh, Jr., or you can even stand where George Washington camped. But that's not all residents love about the glorious area.

Residents know Hunterdon County is all about location. Known as a commuter area, it is an hour's drive to New York City or Philadelphia, yet worlds away from these major cities. While here, you're near the Ivy League school of Princeton, the capital city of Trenton, and nearby Allentown.

Despite all these large cities surrounding it, Hunterdon County is abundant with nature and natural beauty. The county is replete with incredible parks, relaxed riverside towns, abundant shopping areas, and award-winning vineyards. Nature lovers can enjoy the great outdoors by biking, kayaking, or fishing.

If this sounds like somewhere you would love to be, you might be wondering how to find the right fit. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the best neighborhoods in Hunterdon County that embody the essence of this remarkable region. Read on to learn more!


Nestled in the heart of Hunterdon County is the sleepy rural community of Pittstown. It features lush forests, rolling hills, and winding rivers. It shares a boundary with the Franklin, Union, and Alexandria townships. The beauty of Pittstown is its tranquility. Massive farmlands and idyllic backdrops make the area perfect for nature enthusiasts seeking an escape from the outside world. Local businesses offer fresh produce, farm-to-table dining, and unique treasures for your home.

One of the best things about living in Pittstown is the world of adventures that awaits. You can venture out on the nature trails, go bike riding, or relax by the river one day and find something on an entirely different level for the next. If you want to savor fine wines, visit Beneduce Vineyards. When looking for something more daring, you could go skydiving. The options are endless.

Because of the historic feel of Pittstown, many homes are colonial in style. However, ranch style and craftsman designs are also common in the area. In either case, since most properties are prominent in the country, the homes will tend to be larger in stature.


Annandale is the place to be if you enjoy the idea of pure suburban charm.  This small town in Clinton Township is home to the Annandale Historic District. You'll find plenty of history here, with two sites that hold value for their roles in the Revolutionary War: the 1759 Vaught House and the 1760 Jones Tavern.

Annandale is an area with abundant beauty all around. Whether you want to see old architecture or experience wilderness exploration, you'll find it all in this Hunterdon County community. However, as remote as it may seem at first glance, it is far from it, and residents can find many ways to spend lazy afternoons doing what they enjoy.

There are many recreational options for those who live in Annandale. Head to Spruce Run, a swimming area and beach with lifeguards on duty. The lake covers 1,290 acres and holds 11 billion gallons of water. At its deepest point, it can reach over 75 feet.

If you prefer to explore history, the Red Mill Museum Village allows you to get hands-on with history. For a magical view of Annandale, you may soar above the treetops for a bird's-eye view of the lush forest below in a hot-air balloon ride. Regardless of which adventure you choose, there's no limit to the possibilities of what you'll see.


The town of Pottersville is split between Bedminster Township and Tewksbury Township. Both are charming areas with attractive natural features that make them stand out. Pottersville has a fairy tale feel, being nestled along the shore of the Lamington River, the Herzog Brook, and nearby Potters Falls.

Its bountiful nature gives residents many areas to explore when seeking quiet serenity and outdoor excursions. Nearby state parks, including Hacklebarney State Park, are ideal for hiking and for those seeking an active outdoor lifestyle. Whether you enjoy fishing, birding, trail running, or sightseeing, this is the perfect place.

The small-town atmosphere also makes it a favorite location for people seeking a strong community vibe. It is where neighbors bond, connect, and converse over coffee in peaceful restaurants. Many available homes in the area have stood the test of time and are historic in their designs. However, as modern home trends infiltrated the site, so too did the building styles you will find, especially as you step out of the historic district. Therefore, you may find various craftsman, Tudor, and colonial-style homes in combination with modern designs.

Discover which neighborhood in Hunterdon County is right for you

If you're interested in finding the perfect neighborhood in Hunterdon County or already know where you wish to be, expert agent Freeman Smith can help you get there. Just contact him today to discuss buying or selling your New Jersey home.

*Header photo courtesy of Shutterstock

Work With Freeman (Jeff)

Freeman's goal is to simplify a very complicated process and arrive at the very best for you, the client. With over 40 years of sales and negotiating experience, your needs will be placed before everything else.

Follow Me on Instagram